Week 1 NFL preseason grades for first-round rookies: Who stood out, disenchanted and shocked in NFL debut

Week 1 NFL preseason grades for first-round rookies: Who stood out, disenchanted and shocked in NFL debut

What sort of analyst would I be if I did not charge first-round rookies after their first preseason recreation? A disappointing one. And I am not right here to disappoint, however to present you, the reader, what you need. Now, after all, do not learn an excessive amount of into these outcomes. We’re only one showcase in these gamers’ skilled careers — or within the case of the Jaguars and Raiders, two runs.

However now that there is respectable NFL movie to observe, the grades need to be distributed, crap recreation or not.

These are the preseason grades for the primary spherical rookies. Earlier than I start, if a rookie is not listed, it is both as a result of he did not play in his respective crew’s opening recreation or, for varied causes, wasn’t in a position to make an impression in any respect, dangerous or good. .

1. Travon Walker, EDGE/DL, Jaguars

Grade: A-

Most of Walker’s rushes have been stymied, however he is been a strong participant towards the run, had a fumble towards the Browns when he went down the backfield and drew a holding name on Cleveland left sort out Jedrick Wills. His dismissal within the Corridor of Fame recreation was extra on account of Jarrett Stidham’s try to beat him than a person victory by Walker. He had one other hit on Stidham on an out of doors pace that was extra spectacular. Altogether, for a uncooked however freaky athletic specimen, the Jaguars needs to be fairly proud of Walker’s early returns thus far this preseason.

2. Aidan Hutchinson, EDGE, Lions

Class: B

headshot-image

Hutchinson had two tackles on 10 snaps in his preseason debut for the Lions, certainly one of which was a sort out for loss. No stress although. Hopefully we’ll see a bit extra of the No. 1 decide. 2 total earlier than the common season begins.

5. Kayvon Thibodeaux, EDGE, Giants

Class: B

headshot-image

Thibodeaux wasn’t credited with an official snap within the preseason opener towards the Patriots, however was very shut on a number of events. His first hit was a push-pull to the New England proper sort out that introduced the blocker downfield. Thibodeaux did not explode out of the gates, however he hardly regarded misplaced towards the professional expertise.

6. Ikem Ekwonu, OT, Panthers

Grade: A-

headshot-image

Primarily going up towards Montez Sweat and Efe Obada — two tremendous lengthy, athletic operating backs — Ekwonu was sturdy on the level of assault, successful all however certainly one of his reps in cross safety. He received up and beneath these defenders within the run recreation on most events as properly. Sturdy begin for the primary offensive sort out off the board.

7. Evan Neal, OT, Giants

Grade: C+

headshot-image

Neal’s debut may have gone higher. Depth rusher Anfernee Jennings received the perfect of him with a sequence of strikes in a number of one-on-one matchups. The previous Alabama star was caught off steadiness on these reps. For the run and display screen recreation, Neal was snappy and in management, executing what gave the impression to be his project.

9. Charles Cross, OT, Seahawks

Grade: A-

headshot-image

The silky clean cross units that made Cross a high 10 decide have been on full show towards the Steelers over the weekend. After all, he did not see TJ Watt screaming within the nook, however he was sudden and highly effective in his tackles, principally towards Derrek Tuszka, not permitting a stress, though some have been shut.

10. Garrett Wilson, WR, Jets

Grade: B+

headshot-image

Wilson was pressing to beat the press and generate separation comparatively early on his routes within the preseason opener towards the Eagles. He caught two passes for 25 yards. Nothing alarming about his debut.

13. Jordan Davis, DT, Eagles

Grade: C

headshot-image

Davis performed as I anticipated him to — flashed a bit towards the run, pushing the Jets’ middle on one play and swimming previous him on one other, however was a non-factor as a cross rusher. Nevertheless, I’ll say that his measurement alone attracts sufficient consideration contained in the opposition’s offensive line.

14. Kyle Hamilton, S, Ravens

Grade: C+

headshot-image

I will begin with the dangerous — Hamilton missed three dunk makes an attempt towards the Titans. In any other case, he displayed dynamic deep protection capability, incessantly wiping out throwing lanes as they materialized on account of his fluid footwork at his intimidating measurement. If diving efforts flip into clear and beneath management services, Hamilton shall be wonderful.

17. Zion Johnson, OG, Chargers

Grade: A-

headshot-image

Out of the gate, Johnson regarded like a seasoned vet, principally as a result of the Chargers have been operating usually, and Johnson’s extraordinarily low middle of gravity and pure energy are sometimes placed on full show to pave lanes for the bottom recreation. His anchor was strong within the professional cross, save for an overzealous bloat late within the first quarter and a bull rush that started to get to him late within the recreation. General, a optimistic begin for the rookie proper guard.

19. Trevor Penning, OT, Saints

Grade: D+

headshot-image

Within the preseason opener towards the Texans, Penning was hit with the tough actuality that he is now not blocking towards FCS outdoors rushers. He surrendered 5 pressures on simply 27 post-blocking snaps and principally regarded out of types towards any sort of defender utilizing any sort of rush. Comfort: he moved folks within the run recreation.

20. Kenny Pickett, QB, Steelers

Class: B

headshot-image

I noticed a tweet that the Steelers turned their offense into the 2021 Dolphins offense as soon as Pickett entered the operating, and upon watching the movie, that is principally true. From half-turns with first reads within the flat, to fast checks, to broad receiver screens, the Steelers did not ask their first-round decide to do a lot in his preseason debut. That is to not say it was a failure of a efficiency from the rookie. He was decisive and correct with the ball and linked on a powerful in-between shot close to the sideline early within the fourth quarter.

23. Kaiir Elam, CB, Payments

Grade: B-

headshot-image

It was a clear Orchard Park debut for the beginning cornerback, past a cross interference when he was caught trying within the backfield on a cross play. As well as, Elam’s protection was sticky and he had one breakup allowed. For a principally male nook enjoying in a zone-heavy scheme, Elam was quiet however unspectacular.

24. Tyler Smith, OG, Cowboys

Grade: A-

headshot-image

After watching intensive movie of Tulsa zeroing in on Smith throughout the pre-draft course of, the Cowboys’ first-round professional debut went virtually precisely as anticipated. He appeared slightly misplaced at instances, even crashing into middle or sort out. However he battled like hell and demonstrated veteran-like brute energy in stay, man-to-man, professional cross and run recreation situations. Apparently, there was a activity blown into a spot by him that led to a stress. Aside from that, I like how Smith performed towards the Broncos.

26. Jermaine Johnson II, EDGE, Jets

Grade: C

headshot-image

Johnson saved his greatest rush for… first. Sure, his opening snap, from the broad 9 towards Lane Johnson, was his most spectacular of the afternoon towards the Eagles, returning the appropriate punt. Moreover, Johnson regarded the a part of a fast, lengthy first-round decide, however was held in test.

29. Cole Unusual, OG, Patriots

Class: B

headshot-image

First, Unusual will get additional factors for going gloveless in his Patriots preseason debut. Very New England inside blocker. In all seriousness, whereas a bit gradual, Unusual did not look misplaced at left guard in his 13 snaps and the sturdy end he displayed in [Les Snead voice] UT-Chattanooga was conspicuous towards the Giants’ defensive position.

30. George Karlaftis, EDGE, Chiefs

Grade: A-

headshot-image

Karlaftis busted out the complete cross rush arsenal towards the Bears and was very efficient, recording three pressures within the video games during which he was tasked with getting after the quarterback. He regarded explosive and well-armed on the level of assault. Karlaftis gained with a one-arm bull rush, an out of doors rush and a floater later within the recreation. He was left on just a few events towards the run however total had an incredible debut.

31. Daxton Hill, S/CB, Bengals

Grade: B+

headshot-image

Hill was ubiquitous in his first preseason recreation, taking 40 snaps and barely trying misplaced or misplaced. Halfway by the second quarter, he reacted rapidly to a shot up the center and almost missed an interception. He missed a sort out.

32. Lewis Cine, S, Vikings

Class: B

headshot-image

Identical to he confirmed up at Georgia, Cine was razor-quick in protection towards the Raiders to begin his journey by the preseason. He had one sort out on a down route and in any other case did not see a lot of the ball thrown his method.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

A note to our visitors

This website has updated its privacy policy in compliance with changes to European Union data protection law, for all members globally. We’ve also updated our Privacy Policy to give you more information about your rights and responsibilities with respect to your privacy and personal information. Please read this to review the updates about which cookies we use and what information we collect on our site. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our updated privacy policy.